New: Lampway is on the App Store for iPhone and iPad.Download it

Matthew Siljander, MDSubscribe
StoriesLife Changes

Other writing

The Knee Was Never the Whole Problem

Published here

Matthew Siljander smiling on a dirt trail at sunrise.

Walter Freeman drove a van he called the Lobotomobile.

Ice pick through the eye socket. A tap of the hammer. Ten minutes. He sold it as a miracle, and desperate families believed him.

My field has a different version of this.

A surgeon scopes an arthritic knee. Shaves the meniscus. Tells himself he is buying the patient a few years. The data has said otherwise for years. I am buying them a few years is the half truth that lets you keep doing it.

The knee is rarely the whole problem. A person is a body with a history and a set of circumstances. They did better when I treated all three, not just the knee.

People are no different. The ones who changed me did not do it for me. The surgeons in training let me operate before I had proved myself. They saw where I was going and helped me get there.

I built toward one goal for twenty years. A medical diagnosis closed my operating room door at 39. By Freeman's logic that is a total loss.

During some of the toughest moments, I smile. If I'm going to deal with this anyway, I might as well be smiling.

The knee was never the whole problem. Neither was the diagnosis.

During some of the toughest moments, I smile. If I'm going to deal with this anyway, I might as well be smiling.

Matthew Siljander, MDmatthewsiljandermd.com
Share on LinkedIn

Originally on LinkedIn

Your turn

Write back. Suggest a topic. Tell me a story of your own. It comes straight to me.

Please share your own story. Leave out other people's private information.

Sharing your words

Your email stays private. Nothing is posted automatically. If you allow sharing, your story is shared without your name or email. People who know you may still recognize the story.

Topic suggestions may inspire a future post. Your words stay private unless you choose to allow sharing.

Good Thing Monday

One short essay every Monday. Free.