New: Lampway is on the App Store for iPhone and iPad.Download it

Matthew Siljander, MDSubscribe
Good Thing Monday

Good Thing Monday

Past the first answer

First published

Good Thing Monday

The Good Thing Is

The real cause is usually there to find if you keep looking past the first answer.

Share on LinkedIn

Medical school interview day. Butterflies in my stomach. One shot. I had to nail this.

Dr. Harrison asked me what if I told you there was a correlation between ice cream sales and drownings. What would that tell you.

Not much, I told him. Correlation doesn't imply causation.

Years later, my first total hip in practice. A gentleman who had seen a spine surgeon before me. The spine surgeon recommended a major spine revision.

His pain was mostly in his groin. Significant limp. A cane. Walked slowly. Seemed unbalanced.

I got radiographs of his pelvis and hip. His entire femoral head had disintegrated. Disappeared. He didn't have one.

The patient wasn't skeptical. But he'd been told the spine was a big problem, so he figured they were both issues.

Let's do your hip first, I told him. Then we'll think about your spine.

A lot of scar tissue. A lot. Micro steps forward. Two and a half hours.

As I walked out of the room, Bobby McFerrin's Every Little Thing Is Gonna Be All Right was playing.

He told me later the hip surgery helped him a lot. He had the spine surgery anyway. It helped him a little.

Both were real. One was significantly more symptomatic.

Life isn't black and white. If someone says they know 100 percent what caused something, they usually know nothing.

This week, when something keeps going wrong, ask what else could be causing it before you fix what's in front of you.

The good thing is, the real cause is usually there to find if you keep looking past the first answer.

Also published on Substack

Good Thing Monday

One short essay every Monday. Free.

Your turn

Write back. Suggest a topic. Tell me a story of your own. It comes straight to me.

Please share your own story. Leave out other people's private information.

Sharing your words

Your email stays private. Nothing is posted automatically. If you allow sharing, your story is shared without your name or email. People who know you may still recognize the story.

Topic suggestions may inspire a future post. Your words stay private unless you choose to allow sharing.