Other writing
Her X-Rays Said Otherwise
Published here
Being right is important. How you communicate it so the other person actually hears it and feels heard is the key.
Matthew Siljander, MDmatthewsiljandermd.comShe came in ready for a knee replacement. Her X-rays said otherwise.
Late 50s, maybe early 60s. Right knee pain. A few years back, another surgeon in the community told her she was bone-on-bone and needed a new knee. She mulled it over for a long time. The pain kept getting in the way of her life, and she finally decided she was ready.
She asked, "When can we do the knee replacement?"
I looked at her X-rays. Essentially a normal knee. Very little joint space narrowing medially. That was about it.
There are different ways to deliver that news.
One option. "No, he's wrong. You don't have enough arthritis. A knee replacement won't help you. Surgery is not always the answer."
Every word of it is accurate. But, she waited years to say yes. And now she's walking out with the same pain and no answers.
I said it differently.
"Well, the good news is you actually have quite a bit of cartilage left in your knee. A replacement at this point, quite honestly, wouldn't make a big difference in your pain. But you still have knee pain. So we've got to figure that out."
Turned out it was her hip.
That part almost doesn't matter. We could have worked it up and never found an answer. She still would have walked out with a doctor working on it with her.
The X-ray didn't change between those two versions. Neither did the recommendation.
Being right is important. How you communicate it so the other person actually hears it and feels heard is the key.
First acknowledge their problem. Then deliver the news.